What Are BARKSKINS?

Article first published as TV Review: BARKSKINS on Seat42F.

Recently, National Geographic aired the scripted drama BARKSKINS, based on a small part of the Annie Proulx novel of the same name. Now available on Hulu, the eight-episode drama follows French (and a few English) colonizers in the so-called New World, or New France as it was known, in the late 1600s. What would become the United States and Canada is still a wilderness, and the people portrayed live far away from their familiar civilizations. Their best connections back to their homeland are the new arrivals, but those newcomers must adapt quickly to the harsh life of the forest or die. Native Americans fight for their land, while the Europeans bicker amongst one another. It’s a wonder our current society came out of it.

The title BARKSKINS refers to indentured servants who labored three years in return for freedom and a chance at prosperity. Two of the characters in the series, Rene Sel (Christian Cooke, Witches of East End) and Charles Duquet (James Bloor, Shoplifters of the World), are in the titular position. Though, Charles has no intention of serving out his time. They work for Monsieur Claude Trepagny (David Thewlis, the Harry Potter films), who has dreams of building an everlasting city. Will they help him?

It’s actually quite easy to miss that Rene and Charles are supposed to be the leads. Yes, there is a quite a bit of screentime with them, but there’s plenty without them, the show boasting a sweeping cast. Among the most recognizable are Marcia Gay Harden (Code Black), who plays innkeeper Mathilde Geffard, Matthew Lillard (Good Girls) as the sleazy Gus Lafarge, Zahn McClarnon (Longmire), Aneurin Barnard (The White Queen), and Thomas M. Wright (Outsiders). But there are plenty of others besides, representing a wide swath of people that make up the residents of the area.

BARKSKINS is trying to be a sweeping drama, but lacks the feel of one. Quite honestly, most of the characters blur together, and after watching the premiere, it’s hard to actually sit down and pick out each player and actor (sans beards in their IMBD photos). It’s not confusing, exactly, since the same players tend to stay in scenes together. But picking up names is difficult, and without the context and backstory as the show begins, harder still. Lots of these characters have pasts, but they are slow to reveal them to the audience.

The production looks fantastic, of course. This is clearly a show with a budget, or at least they spent it on look. Period costumes and miles of actual wilderness help BARKSKINS feel like it’s another time and place, nature only beginning to be spoiled by man. But it lacks the epic feel that compelling characters and a sweeping score could lend it to kick it up a few notches. There are a number of recent shows that have achieved a similar thing with a lot more filled out than BARKSKINS presents, leaving this more like a cable also-ran than an awards contender. It doesn’t feel like a show that’s going to amass a following and run for very long.

Also confusing, while it is a National Geographic series, and NatGeo’s website boasts that you can watch your favorite shows from them on Disney+, don’t look for this one among the offerings on the new streaming app. Surprisingly, it IS on Hulu, so you can find it if you want it and are up on your streaming subscriptions. It’s just not in the obvious place.

All in all, I can’t say BARKSKINS is disappointing because I’d heard almost nothing about it and no expectations had been built up. But it doesn’t feel like the type of series that will be a sleeper hit, either. It’s fine, no major complaints other than the size of the cast and lack of distinguishing characteristics and personalities (at least initially). Just nothing special.

As mentioned, you can watch BARKSKINS now on Hulu.

Is (CODE) BLACK the New Grey's?

Article originally published as CODE BLACK Review on Seat42F.

CBS, usually the home of crime procedurals these days, decided to try its hand at a medical one with CODE BLACK. Set in a busy emergency room, the title refers to the state the staff goes into if there are not enough personnel and resources to handle the patients coming through the door. While many medical facilities may see this occasionally, the one at the center of the show, LA County Hospital, goes through it on a regular basis, nearly every day of the year.

CODE BLACK is high energy fun. From the start to the finish of the episode, a lot occurs because the tempo of the setting is a very busy one. While the premise would not work at most hospitals, the specific scenario chosen seems realistic enough, and the pacing keeps things interesting. Viewers will not have time to get bored.

But it isn’t always realistic. The trap any medical show falls into is that the cases must be unique in order to engage the audience. House, M.D. kind of got around this limitation because of the nature of the unit that Dr. House ran, but most series, such as Grey’s Anatomy, just decide to suspend reality in this aspect of the program in order to make more compelling stories. Judging by the pilot, CODE BLACK does the same. I don’t know that this is strictly a negative aspect, since so many other shows do the same thing, but it is worth noting.

Credit goes to the production design, which makes the LA County Hospital look much more authentic than in other medical dramas. The white board shows signs of being erased many times over without a good cleaning, and the paint is cracked and peeling. Too many television programs go for the stylistic look, to their detriment, and the approach CODE BLACK takes lends more credibility to the presentation.

What a lot of crime shows forget to do is to make the characters the center of the show, and medical dramas tend to not have that problem as much. Sure, there are patients to treat constantly coming through the door, and most will not return for another hour. But while the focus of the majority of CBS’s fare is the investigation, with character moments saved primarily for the beginning and ends of the hour, medical series tend to focus on emotional arcs for their players throughout the installments, even while they are dealing with the emergencies. CODE BLACK is no different in this regard, which already gives it a leg up on its same-network peers (save The Good Wife, which operates in a similar manner, favoring character over formula).

CODE BLACK’s ensemble is delightful and given decent material. The person with the most authority on the floor, the renowned Dr. Leanne Rorish (Marcia Gay Harden, Trophy Wife), has gone through a tragedy that worries her former student and fellow doc, Neal Hudson (Raza Jaffrey, Smash). Together, along with long-serving Dr. Rollie Guthrie (William Allen Young, Moesha), they manage four new residents who have been assigned to them (played by Golden Boy’s Bonnie Somerville, The Brink’s Melanie Chandra, The Joneses’ Benjamin Hollingsworth, and relative newcomer Harry Ford). They are all cared for by ‘Mommy’ senior nurse Jesse Sallander (Luis Guzman, How to Make It in America).

When compared to others of its kind, CODE BLACK is more enjoyable and intriguing than most. I can’t say it has any single element that makes it stand out in particular, but I really like the chemistry of the cast, which is the heart of the show. It could be my new Grey’s Anatomy (which I love dearly) when that show goes off the air, but for now, it’s one of the few new broadcast shows this fall I consider worth watching. It lacks depth and falls a bit short on realism, but it’s still very entertaining overall.

CODE BLACK premieres Wednesday, September 30^th at 10 p.m. ET on CBS.

Take Home a TROPHY WIFE

Article first published as TROPHY WIFE Review on Seat42F.

One of ABC’s new sitcoms is called TROPHY WIFE. Young-acting party girl Kate (Malin Akerman, Watchmen, Childrens Hospital) meets the guy of her dreams after falling off the stage while singing karaoke. But she soon learns that marrying him means taking on three children and two ex-wives, giving her an instant family.

The name of the show may be TROPHY WIFE, but Kate is anything but that negative label. She is a warm-hearted individual who puts her all into everything she does, including being a wife and stepmother. Kate wants to be the best parent she can be for the kids, plays nice with the exes, and truly seems to love Pete (Bradley Whitford, The West Wing, The Cabin in the Woods), her new man.

We see this when Kate eagerly takes a parent-teacher conference with stepson Warren’s teacher (Phyllis Smith, The Office), and as she covers for Warren’s twin sister, Hillary (listed as Once Upon a Time’s Bailee Madison on the show’s official website, though played by someone else in the “Pilot”). Even when Kate is mad at Hillary for bringing vodka to school or uncomfortable about Warren’s (Ryan Scott Lee, Super 8) seeming lust for her, Kate tries to make the situation right without judgment or anger.

Not that Kate’s best is good enough for Warren and Hillary’s mother, stuffy Doctor Diane (Marcia Gay Harden, The Newsroom, Mystic River). Diane is icy from the start, definitely not approving of Pete’s latest relationship skewing younger, or having her children around such an influence.

Still, Diane is preferable to Pete’s second wife, Jackie (Michaela Watkins, Enlightened, Wanderlust), a flighty, sneaky, liar who has no trouble hiding the death of her son, Bert’s (Albert Tsai), hamster from him, or hiding a key to get into Pete’s house. Jackie is trouble, especially when she considers herself still part of the family, clearly having nothing else of significance going on in her life.

Now, as I recently complained about in another review, there are a lot of family sitcoms out there, so we don’t necessarily need any more. Yet, TROPHY WIFE doesn’t feel like most others. It’s sort of a mix between Modern Family and The New Normal in tone, showing a more blended clan much more common today in the world, though underrepresented on television, than in years past. As such, it’s another type of family series, not the same old thing over again.

It also helps that Akerman is a capable leading lady, playing both the emotionally charged scenes and the over-the-top physical comedy with great acumen. In the presence of Whitford, Watkins, and Harden, all very talented in their own right, this group delivers a very funny premiere episode.

Kate is a very likeable character who seems authentic, even if she isn’t relatable. She is still in touch with the things that make up her personality, maintaining a great relationship with drinking buddy and bartender Meg (another wonderful performer, White Collar’s Natalie Morales). Yet, as Meg takes Kate’s developments in stride, it helps the viewers understand that Kate hasn’t changed and isn’t trying to, just moving into the next phase of a full life.

One does begin to wonder what kind of man Pete is. We see him as the calming influence when everyone is together, but there are definitely some different facets to him to marry three so very different women. He seems to be totally committed to Kate, and one assumes he was equally so to Jackie and Diane during their tenures, though I’m curious to see why those pairings feel apart. He’s a loving father, but one with flaws, such as having trouble being honest with a child about a dead pet. I look forward to learning more about him.

Now, this being a pilot, there are a few things the show can improve on. For one, it would be nice if it was a little more consistent with its tone. I’d also like to see more cohesive, focused stories, as this episode meanders around a lot among the various characters. But I dig the energy and the cast quite a bit, so I think it will be something worth keeping an eye on. As long as it allows Akerman the opportunity to continue on Childrens Hospital.

TROPHY WIFE premieres Tuesday, September 24^th at 9:30 p.m. ET on ABC, and the “Pilot” is available on Hulu now.

THE NEWSROOM - "Election Night: Part II" Review

Article first published as THE NEWSROOM - "Election Night: Part II" Review on TheTVKing.

With the fate of HBO's The Newsroom officially still undecided, despite what star Jeff Daniels tweets, this week's season two finale, "Election Night: Part II," may very well serve as a series finale for the Aaron Sorkin drama. If it does, it will be a great loss for television, a medium that is bettered by such intelligent writing, bold characters, and inspiring stories, showing the media how they should be reporting. But in terms of closure, the episode satisfies pretty well.

"Election Night: Part II" has the team covering the results of the 2012 election, while waiting for the hammer to drop after the Genoa fiasco. Will (Daniels), MacKenzie (Emily Mortimer) and Charlie (Sam Waterston) are trying to resign to spare their colleagues' careers. Yet, the rest of the senior staff plans on leaving, too, showing their solidarity. This angers Will, but insults the others when he insists they not do this folly. They stick together and do the right thing; he taught them that.

One fantastic element of The Newsroom is the cohesion of the gang who work at ACN. These are not just co-workers, these are friends. They are united in a noble mission, and without the heads of the organization, the mission would fail, making the job not worth having. It is essential for everyone to stay together, and even after losing all credibility for Genoa, they can only recover by remaining on the job, working to build themselves back up.

This is the decision both Leona (Jane Fonda) and Reese (Chris Messina) come to, too. The heads of the company will not accept any resignations because they've studied the evidence and know that even though Genoa was false, the newsroom did as thorough job as possible given what they had. The snake Jerry Dantana (Hamish Linklater) screwed them; they didn't screw themselves.

I don't know why Charlie can't be gracious with Reese when Reese decides not to accept their resignations. Yes, Charlie has already decided that they will withdrawal their offers to quit, but he and Reese so rarely see eye to eye, he should celebrate, not fight, when this occurs. Yet, perhaps emotions are just running unusually high, as Charlie spends much of the episode yelling, faced with losing the profession he loves deeply, and so he can't bring himself to make nice with someone he considers so despicable.

It's funny how Reese and Leon have changed sides this year, now supporting those they tried to fire not so far in the past. I think crisis have a way of bringing people together, and also ACN being disgraced personally shames the Lansings, so they want to fight back, for their names as well as the network's. Even if their motivations are selfish, it's sure nice to see the pair of them in the room at the end, joining our beloved heroes.

We know The Newsroom's crew is righteous because even the lawyer who takes their depositions, Rebecca Halliday (Marcia Gay Harden), thinks so, and she seems a tough one to win over. She vows to defend them and argues against settlement. I hope she sticks around for a possible third season, as she will be needed to help with the major hanging thread of the Dantana plot, Don's (Thomas Sadoski) defamation lawsuit.

The Newsroom can never just do one thing at a time, though, so "Election Night: Part II" is about more than just the decision of who should stay and who should go. They also get to cover the 2012 election results, which is done in a very entertaining way. From Will constantly cutting off Sloan (Olivia Munn), to Neal (Dev Patel) being tasked with helping Sloan and MacKenzie with trivial things, to the bickering with the D.C. anchor, to Will gleefully sparring with Taylor Warren (Constance Zimmer), there's a lot to watch, and all of it very, very fun.

Taylor is another familiar face I'd like to see return. She ingrains herself in several characters, and her inquiry about having Jim (John Gallagher Jr.) work for her appears to be sincere. She's a sassy, combative type who unintentionally causes trouble, but her heart is in the right place, and she's a fair judge of character, even amongst people she disagrees with. She makes quite the impression this season, and the show could use more of her in the future.

Alas, any episode of The Newsroom would not be complete without some romantic stuff. Sloan and Don finally share a kiss in a spectacular, public fashion. This has been simmering all year, even if it usually is a very minor part of the subplot, and it's gratifying to see them get together, especially if this is it for the show.

Will and MacKenzie have an even better story, getting their feelings and secrets out in the open. MacKenzie is able to get the chance to explain her actions, with Will actually paying attention, and Will admits to wrongdoing, too. The viewers get to understand where both have been coming from, which leads to even more of an urge to see them put the past behind and get this couple together. They do, as Will produces the ring he lied about returning and proposes!

I don't think the dynamic of The Newsroom will change at all with Mac and Will married. They will still disagree and do all the things they normally do because they are passionate about their jobs and have always been united on that front. This doesn't change that. Unlike other shows where adjustments must be made for such a development, the only thing different will be them not pining over one another. Very cool.

The third couple fans root for is Jim and Maggie (Alison Pill), but they are not in a good place to be together, and any union at this point would seem false. That's probably why "Election Night: Part II" just has them bonding as friends over a screwed up call, and has Jim working to fix things between Maggie and her estranged roommate, Lisa (Kelen Coleman). Besides, Jim is happy with Hallie (Grace Gummer), as he should be, as it is a healthy relationship. Maybe, seasons down the line, this could change, but for now, they are where they should be.

Is The Newsroom the perfect show? Of course not. Characters frequently deliver parables instead of answering questions. The succeed as heroes when realistically they would fail. Personal moments happen most often in their place of business. And sometimes people devolve into caricatures. Yet, these aren't complaints because they are done so well, and are part of the charm of the fabric. The things that make it schmaltzy also make it awesome, and so while it isn't perfect, it is pretty darn good, and I sincerely hope it comes back, as it ranks among my favorite shows on the air right now. Even if Charlie acts a little too one-note in this episode, and I disliked knowing Genoa was a bomb from the start of the season.

HBO will likely announce the fate of The Newsroom soon.

THE NEWSROOM Declares "Let's Kill All The Lawyers"

Article first published as THE NEWSROOM Review Season 2 Premiere on Seat42F.

Grade: 91%

HBO’s THE NEWSROOM is back for a second season with “First Thing We Do, Let’s Kill All the Lawyers.” The main part of the story takes place two weeks after the events of last year’s finale, and the various characters must deal with the consequences of their actions, both professional and personal. If you have not yet watched the episode, I recommend viewing it before reading this review, to avoid anything being spoiled, as the various story points will be discussed below.

Will McAvoy (Jeff Daniels) is a subdued man in “First Thing We Do, Let’s Kill All the Lawyers.” Although he is fired up and passionate when dubbing the Tea Party ‘The American Taliban,’ he now must pay the price for doing so, namely, being pulled off of the network’s 9/11 tenth anniversary coverage. He deals with this by drinking and smoking and becoming a wimp on-air again.

While it is absolutely in keeping with his character to go back and forth between fearless crusader and appeasing ratings-whore, one must wonder how long the see-saw can continue. Will’s spirits are already bolstered multiple times in the first year alone, and it would suck if none of those efforts have lasting effects, always returning him to the same sad state in their aftermath. Will must find a way to break this cycle, committing to the persona he wants most.

It is my opinion that the way for him to do this is to be with Mackenzie McHale (Emily Mortimer). She still doesn’t know what is in the voice mail Will leaves her while high, but it’s obvious that she is sensing his anger towards her cooling, and is intending to reform as much of a bond with him as he will let her. She calls him in the middle of the night, and shares a drink with him at the bar. It can’t possibly be much longer before they are a couple again, and in that relationship, Will might finally stabilize.

Though where is Lonny (Terry Crews) during this installment? Why do we not see him guarding Will in the bar? Hopefully, Lonny’s absence is temporary, just an oversight caused by not needing the actor enough to warrant an appearance in this particular episode.

In keeping on the romantic track, Jim (John Gallagher Jr.) is unwilling to be friends with Maggie (Alison Pill) after she chooses to move in with Don (Thomas Sadoski), and so takes an assignment following the Romney campaign, where he is shunned for Will’s Taliban comment. This doesn’t seem like the environment where wounded Jim can heal, certainly not a comforting, supporting one, but maybe concentrating on work is what he needs. And if he finds victory in reporting the story, that could help. Running may seem cowardly to some, but Maggie has made her choice, so it’s understandable why Jim would find it hard to be around her, and perhaps he’s wise to get himself out of that environment.

Except, Jim may actually still have a chance with Maggie, as Don finds a YouTube video of her rant about Jim, and promptly decides they are over as a couple. I am very dissatisfied with this quick evaporation of their romance. Don and Maggie have plenty of ups and downs, but two weeks is all they can make it? Maggie chooses Don; that should count for something. And it seemed so fresh and realistic that Jim and Maggie weren’t going to ever be together because Maggie would be with Don, no matter what viewers thought should happen, and this has been ruined. Though, Maggie clearly won’t just have a happy ending with Jim, given her appearance in future scenes, which I’ll get to shortly.

This does leave open the possibility of a Don / Sloan (Olivia Munn) pairing now. Things are plenty awkward between the two, since Sloan confesses her feelings for him, even though Don isn’t holding it over her in any way. But now that he’s single, maybe after a short, respectful pause, he may pursue Sloan, thus solving at least one rocky dynamic in the workplace. Although is Don gets with Sloan too quickly, that could screw up Maggie even more.

Because of Jim’s absence, a producer out of Washington D.C., Jerry Dantana (Hamish Linklater, The New Adventures of Old Christine), is tapped to fill in for him. Jerry is immediately a hindrance, vaguely appearing to be a team player, but also having his own ambitions. We don’t know all of the details yet, but Jerry and the guest that he brings onto a panel will definitely set off a huge mistake involving Genoa.

Genoa is a secret military that has landed the staff in very hot water, as evidenced by the fourteen-months-later framing scenes in “First Thing We Do, Let’s Kill All the Lawyers” in which Will, Mackenzie, and Maggie are seen with a team of lawyers led by Rebecca Halliday (Marcia Gay Harden, Damages). Our beloved characters are in trouble after a string of unfortunate events, one of which leads Maggie to Africa and a terrible hair cut and coloring. Bringing in Jerry is a huge mistake they will all regret. Too bad, he seems so nice-ish.

I’m a little tired of television shows doing the flashback to death. THE NEWSROOM is only the latest in a long line of series using that technique lately, and it’s been being done way too often. I’d rather see the Genoa disaster unfold slowly, not realizing that there’s trouble until it’s too late, like the characters do, rather than getting a puzzle piece by piece. I know this trope can be implemented effectively when done right, and THE NEWSROOM is brilliantly written, but in this case, I feel it is a big, easily avoidable misstep.

There are two smaller plots unfolding, too, that may have some big impact. In the first, Neal (Dev Patel) gets involved with Occupy Wall Street. For Neal, this story is both a far-out, unlikely movement, and something playing to his prowess with social media, so it straddles the two interests we’ve known him to have. Those who remember the protests know that they get lots of attention for a short time, but don’t go anywhere, so this is both an opportunity for Neal, professionally, and another dead end for him to pursue, the perfect plot for the character.

In the second, Charlie (Sam Waterson) chooses to pull Will off of the 9/11 special. This is something very uncharacteristic, in that he chooses to bench Will with nearly zero pressure from Leona (Jane Fonda) and Reese (Chris Messina) to do so. Weird; Charlie always defends Will. Did Reese getting kicked out of SOPA scare Charlie that much? It doesn’t seem like it should, in keeping with Charlie’s established personality. I wonder what’s going on there?

THE NEWSROOM is a fantastic series that deftly balances character-driven drama with real-world events and a commentary on the state of journalism. It takes the big stories we’re familiar with, and makes them personal to people we watch on screen and care about. There are a number of new arcs introduced in this season premiere which promise a great season, even if the episode itself lacks any of the stellar, inspiring moments that were a hallmark of the first year. Once we get past the weird flashbacks, I think that will sort itself out.

THE NEWSROOM airs Sundays at 10 p.m. ET on HBO.