Elect THE POLITICIAN

Article first published as TV Review: THE POLITICIAN on Seat42F.

Ryan Murphy, Brad Falchuk, and Ian Brennan, the minds behind FOX’s former shows Glee and Scream Queens, have re-teamed for a new Netflix drama entitled THE POLITICIAN. Like their previous efforts, this one centers on young people who act in hyperreal ways, working hard towards single-minded goals with little regard for who they hurt. These kids act like unscrupulous adults, but the show doesn’t prove they aren’t, instead existing within the high stakes laid out by the protagonists, no tongue in cheek wink that the real world will make this all seem trivial in retrospect.

There is a particular style and tone to THE POLITICIAN. Murphy and Falchuk work with high production concepts in American Horror Story, Pose, and their other television series. But this one is a bit different. It’s more like a Wes Anderson flick than their usual work, down to the young, precocious male lead, characters standing stock still in specific places, and the occasional shot of a furniture description page. THE POLITICIAN’s characters aren’t as odd as those in an Anderson work, and it can sometimes take a viewer out of the story here. But overall, it’s mostly a quality work.

Ben Platt (Pitch Perfect) stars as Payton Hobart. Adopted by the ultra-wealthy Georgina (Gwyneth Paltrow, Avengers) and Keaton (Bob Balaban, Gosford Park), Payton feels less valued than his parents’ biological twins, Martin and Luther (Trevor and Trey Eason). Perhaps to make himself noticed, Payton makes it his mission in life to become president of the United States. His immediate focus: win the presidency of his student body. Which is easier said than done with pretty boy and popular kid River Barkley (David Corenswet, Moe & Jerryweather) standing in his way.

There are others involved, of course. Payton wants cancer patient Infinity Jackson (Zoey Deutch, Ringer) as his running mate to get the sympathy vote, not being aware of what Infinity’s Aunt Dusty (Jessica Lange, American Horror Story) is up to. River’s girlfriend, Astrid (Lucy Boynton, Gypsy), is a serious impediment, and Payton’s girlfriend, Alice (Julia Schlaepfer, Charlie Says), might be one, too. Payton’s advisors, McAfee (Laura Dreyfuss, Glee) and James (Theo Germaine, Adam), don’t always see eye to eye.

Yes, Payton has advisors. The election is treated almost as seriously as an adult campaign would be, and the stakes are just as high if Payton wants to achieve his dreams.

Platt is perfectly cast, playing a role so close to his Tony-winning turn in Evan Hanson. There’s even a dead guy and a crisis of conscience for him to play off of. The rest of the cast seem similarly well suited to their roles.

If I have one complaint about THE POLITICIAN, it’s that it seems very convoluted. There’s a lot going on, and circumstances change quickly with each new twist, of which there are many. Plenty of small moving parts could blow up and derail things at any time. However, other Murphy projects have been similarly dense and came out pretty well, so I think it’s best to have patience and wait. Besides, the character study of Payton seems rich on its own, at least from the first couple of episodes, and may be worth it even if the overall plot is less than satisfying, as has been the case on a couple of seasons of American Horror Story.

If you like Ryan Murphy and flair, you’ll probably like THE POLITICIAN. If you don’t like his other work, don’t expect anything too different here. Not that Murphy is one-note by any means, but he does what he does very well, and this is another variation on those themes.

THE POLITICIAN’s eight-episode first season is available now on Netflix.

Rescue 9-1-1

Article first published as TV Review: 9-1-1 on Seat42F.

Before watching, one can be forgiven for dismissing the new FOX series, 9-1-1, as a typical procedural. After all, it stars firemen, police women, and EMTs, and the people they help don’t carry over from week to week. But there is a lot more to it than that, even if it’s hard to define exactly what the quality is that it exudes. Let’s try to break it down, shall we?

First, there’re the brains behind 9-1-1: Ryan Murphy, Brad Fulchuk, and Tim Minear. These guys are known for a variety of high-quality cable shows in recent years, most notably American Horror Story, American Crime Story, and Feud. Given those credits, it’s hard to believe they would deliver anything at all close to a run-of-the-mill, case-of-the-week series. And they do not.

The next clue that this will be better than usual are the actors who signed up. Angela Bassett (American Horror Story, Olympus Has Fallen) is Athena Grant, the main police person we see in the cast. Peter Krause (Parenthood) is Bobby Nash, the fire captain. Kenneth Choi (Sons of Anarchy, Last Man on Earth), Aisha Hinds (Underground, Dollhouse), and Oliver Stark (Into the Badlands) all play characters who work for Bobby. Connie Britton (Friday Night Lights, Nashville) is a 9-1-1 operator named Abby Clark serving as go-between for all of these people, making it a rounded series. While it’s true that none of them have spotless resumes, to have so many great performers in one series says something.

The premise itself does feel a bit formulaic when described. In the pilot alone, the characters respond to several calls for help, and deal with the issues. One of the ensemble gets in trouble at work for acting inappropriately, one is a recovering alcoholic, and Athena is dealing with marital issues with husband Michael (Rockmond Dunbar, Prison Break). None of these things sound like they belong to a new, promising show.

However, there is something more to 9-1-1 that transcends the formula. It’s an ineffable element that is hard to define completely. The best way I can describe it is that there is an urgency, a pacing and tone, that belongs on a high-quality cable show, and feels very out of place on a broadcast network. No scene comes across as cheesy, everything is done with sincerity, and when paired with the performing talent, it rises above the sum of its parts.

The primary thing I can say is that numerous bits of the pilot moved me deep in my gut. I welled up, but not in the way This Is Us makes me. I experienced adrenaline rushes, but not as I do when watching 24. I was scared, but not like a bad slasher flick evokes. I really felt the emotions the characters were feeling, and I have to say, that is quite a feat to do in an hour procedural, let alone multiple times. Maybe it was the mood I was in, but having just reviewed a terrible show right before it, I don’t think so.

Some will dismiss this assertion and find it ridiculous. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, and I’ve already seen some negative reviews of 9-1-1. But I loathe crime procedurals and watch far too much TV to think I haven’t become desensitized. What I can tell you is that this one feels different. This one makes me eager to watch more. It might be the best show FOX has aired in years, and I don’t think that’s making a questionable boast. This is what a procedural should be, the best of its genre.

9-1-1 airs Wednesdays at 9/8c on FOX.

American Horror Story scares up a Blu-ray release

When American Horror Story premiered last fall on FX, it was immediately apparent that this was a different type of show. Going far creepier than most television ever dares to, it's about the Harmon family, who move into a haunted house in L.A. It is, strangely enough, from the team that brought us Glee and Nip/Tuck, Ryan Murphy and Brad Fulchuk, and we were promised the first season, now released on Blu-ray and DVD, was a stand alone story.

What no one told us ahead of time is that it would be so darn good. For 12 hours, viewers were kept on the edge of their seats as twist after twist played out. We learned about all of the past residents of the house, most of whom died gruesomely and still haunt the building. We learned what the Harmons would do under pressure. We learned that a house can have a life of its own, and that the residents who dwell within are only one small chapter of a larger volume.

The Harmons arrive with problems already brewing. Wife, Vivien (Connie Britton, Friday Night Lights), had recently given birth to a stillborn baby, then learned of husband, Ben's (Dylan McDermott, The Practice), cheating ways. The mistress, Ben's student, Hayden (Kate Mara, 127 Hours), actually follows them out from Boston, making sure that the issues they are fleeing from don't just disappear. Daughter, Violet (Taissa Farmiga), is frustrated with all of the adults, who can't seem to grow up, and suffering from depression.

But then they meet a host of new characters that bring their own set of challenges for the Harmons. A man in a rubber suit (Vivien wrongly believes that it's Ben) has sex with Vivien and impregnates her. A burned man named Larry (Denis O'Hare, True Blood) follows Ben around and wants to help him take care of Hayden once and for all. Neighbor Constance (Oscar winner Jessica Lange, Big Fish) knows more than she lets on. And Violet falls in with a possibly homicidal lad named Tate (Evan Peters, Invasion), who has a connection to a strange and violent creature living in the basement.

If that sounds like a lot, it's just the tip of the iceberg. The large recurring cast of season one includes: a maid who usually appears old (Frances Conroy, Six Feet Under), but looks young and hot (Alexandra Breckenridge, Dirt) to Ben; an abortion doctor (Matt Ross, Big Love) and his wife (Lily Rabe), who so desperately wants a baby; a nosy real estate agent (Christine Estabrook, Mad Men, Desperate Housewives); Constance's daughter with Downs syndrome (Jamie Brewer); a noble security guard (Morris Chestnut, V); a psychic (Sarah Paulson, Studio 60 On the Sunset Strip); and the gay couple to whom the rubber suit belonged (Teddy Sears, Raising the Bar, and Zachary Quinto, Star Trek, Heroes). This large ensemble means that no haunted house convention goes ignored.

The writing, acting, and production are all top notch in American Horror Story, which led to seventeen Emmy nominations and a host of other accolades. Jessica Lange won an Emmy, Golden Globe, and Screen Actor's Guild award for her role as Constance. These were completely deserved, as American Horror Story is something truly original, taking the genre to a new level when allowed to live amongst such well developed characters for so many hours.

Blu-ray is definitely the way to go to get the full affect of American Horror Story. Obviously, there are special effects, and you won't want to miss any elements of those. Also, the masterful score will be much more effective in high definition surround sound. American Horror Story creates such a detailed, engrossing world, with its rich blacks and attention to detail, it is best experienced in the most immersive way possible, which is currently Blu-ray.

This Blu-ray set includes a number of special features. There's The Murder House guide done by the fictional Eternal Darkness Tours of Hollywood, a making of featurette, a focus on the title sequence, introductions to the various ghosts that live in the house, and audio commentary for the "Pilot" episode. This is plenty to satisfy most fans of the show.

Plus, how many series actually give you a conclusion after a mere twelve episodes? Season two, premiering soon, will be in a new place and time, with many of the actors returning, but in different roles. Season one is a complete tale, from beginning to end, making this three-disc set like a very long, very good movie.

 American Horror Story The Complete First Season is available now.

If you like my reviews, please follow me on Twitter! Check out my website, JeromeWetzel.com! Article first published as Blu-ray Review: American Horror Story The Complete First Season on Blogcritics.

American Horror Story frightening and confusing

     From the creators of Glee, Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk, comes American Horror Story, which has been called pretty much the opposite of Glee. Vivian Harmon (Connie Britton, Friday Night Lights) must give birth to a baby that dies seven months into the pregnancy. She seeks comfort by buying a dog.

     Feeling rejected, Vivian's husband Ben (Dylan McDermott,The Practice) cheats on her, and she catches him. To try to save their crumbling marriage, they move across the country and purchase a bargain of a house, whose last owners died in a murder-suicide.

     And that's when things start going really wrong. While sleepwalking, Ben plays with fire. Interesting, considering that a man named Larry (Denis O'Hare, True Blood) keeps approaching him, claiming that the house made Larry burn his family alive. Meanwhile, Vivian has kinky sex with a man in a leather suit, assuming, wrongly, that it's Ben. She becomes pregnant, but is it Ben's, or the suit man's? Plus, daughter Violet (Taissa Farmiga) likes to cut herself, neighbors enter without warning, and something strange and dangerous lives in the basement.

     As far as scary goes, American Horror Story is definitely that; it will make you scared to walk into dark rooms of your own house. The creepiness comes fast and frequently. To make matters worse, it's hard to understand everything that goes on around the family.

     Since the characters aren't given explanations, neither are the viewers. At least understanding an issue can make it less frightening. The fact that most is unknown makes it even scarier.

     Calling it the opposite of Glee may be inaccurate. After all, Glee thrives in the cliches of musicals, often going for stereotypical, larger-than-life characters and stories because that is the tradition in the genre. American Horror Story does the same sort of play with thriller tropes. It uses fast-cut scenes and creepy music to set the mood. Vivian walks up into a dark attic, even as viewers at home are screaming "No! Don't go in there!" Young twins Troy and Brian (Bodhi and Kai Schulz) are slaughtered, and then appear as ghosts. There's nothing creepier than dead twins! There are illusions, mind control, and monsters, each played to maximum fright potential. So perhaps American Horror Story is what the Glee guys do best, applied to a different genre.

     The questions come fast and furious, and few are answered in "Pilot." The Harmon family is immediately in over their heads, and don't even realize it yet. American Horror Story's "Pilot" excels at setting up much intrigue, but leaving viewers in suspense, a surefire way to keep them coming back week after week. I'm not sure I understand yet exactly what the series is trying to do, but with the sex factor, a common play in the suspense genre, combined with some truly excellent mysteries which are hard to define, the series succeeds in setting up something truly special. There is no other show currently like it on television, nor does a past one spring to mind, which is plenty enough to set it apart.

     How does the house control people? What is neighbor Constance's (Jessica Lange, Big Fish) connection? She comes to Ben just before he burns his hand on the stove and tells him it's not his time yet. Does she choose when the house pushes its residents over the edge? Why and how? What is the point in waiting? Are the Harmons already so much out of control of their own lives that they don't realize all the strange things happening? Why does Constance's daughter, Adelaide (Jamie Brewer), keep going into the house, telling people they are going to die? Is she warning them, or threatening them?

     Plus, there is the mystery of the maid. Soon after the Harmons move in, Moira (Frances Conroy, Six Feet Under) shows up, saying that she is the long-time cleaner of the house. Vivian, initially against hiring her, is persuaded to do so. This makes sense, because Moira demonstrates much knowledge about caring for the older elements of the building, which Vivian is clueless about. But then Ben sees Moira as a young, sexy woman (Alexandra Breckenridge, The Ex List), whom he catches masturbating, and is tempted to sleep with. The different perceptions are unexplained, but ratchet up the freaky factor several fold. The transition between the two actresses, especially in the seduction scene, is disturbing, to say the least.

     Then, there is Ben's patient, Tate (Evan Peters, Invasion), who is psychotic. He dreams of murdering people that he likes. Violet somehow strikes up a friendship with him (does Ben not escort his patient out of his house?), and the two become close, sharing secrets. Though Tate tells her one should never hurt those he loves. When Violet is threatened by a bully, Tate convinces her to lure the girl to the basement of the Harmons' home, where Tate and some goblin-like creature hurt and terrify her. It also disturbs Violet, but Tate acts like nothing is wrong. So is he part of the house, too, and can come and go as he pleases? Or is he just such a dark soul that he is drawn in by whatever dwells there?

     American Horror Story lives in a specific world, with set rules that govern it, just like all worlds. The more creepy characters get these rules, and know how to not just survive, but thrive within them. They may even contribute to creating them, though how in control any of them are is uncertain. Since the show seems so sure of itself, it definitely holds an attraction, even for those confused. We might not get what it is going for, yet, but there's a confidence behind it that says that the writers and producers do. This is masterful film making and storytelling, more than worth a watch.


     Check out American Horror Story Wednesdays at 10 p.m. ET on FX.

     If you like my reviews, please follow me on Twitter!

Article first published as TV Review: American Horror Story - "Pilot" on Blogcritics.