Article first published as 'Star Trek: Discovery' - Is It Worthy? on Blogcritics.
I have been a
Star Trek fan almost as long as I can remember. When I was very young, I asked my dad to pick up
Star Wars for me from the library. He brought me
Star Trek: The Motion Picture instead, and I was hooked.
This past fall and winter brought the first season of the latest
Star Trek television series,
Star Trek: Discovery.
Disco, as fans are already calling it, is set in the prime universe (a.k.a. where all
Star Trek
has taken place except the most recent three films). It takes place ten
years before the original series, and about two years after the first
pilot, “The Cage.” Now, with the fifteen-episode first season complete,
it seems an opportune time to ask, is this the triumphant return of
Star Trek on the small screen?
The following contains major spoilers from throughout the first season, including the finale.
Idealism and Morality
The most obvious way
Disco matches up to its predecessors is
keeping the spirit of Starfleet and the United Federation of Planets,
the military and political organization portrayed in the franchise,
alive. Despite the darkness of war that pervades this run, our central
crew is committed to the right ideals. While Captain Lorca (Jason
Isaacs) seemed to stray early on; the revelation that he was Mirror
Universe Lorca the whole time made his actions make sense. In the end,
even when Earth itself was threatened, and with a wavering Admiral
Cornwall (Jayne Brook) and Ambassador Sarek (James Frain) considering
genocide, the crew of the
Disco demanded better.
Besides the obvious saving of the Klingon home world, the best
example of these values comes in the penultimate episode, when Ash Tyler
(Shazard Latif), exposed as being a surgically-altered Voq, feels
ashamed and alone. Cadet Tilly (Mary Wiseman) sits at his empty lunch
table with him and others follow suit. Also, the way the tardigrade is
freed without consequence when its pain is realized is excellent. This
proves that the Starfleet attitude we know is alive and well in the new
series.
Diversity in the Production
This trend of inclusion and acceptance continues behind-the-scenes,
as well. Obviously, the cast is quite diverse, probably the most ever
for
Star Trek. Though the series has always had a history of showing different peoples working side-by-side in common cause.
Disco boasts the first African-American female lead for
Star Trek
in Michael Burnham (Sonequa Martin-Green). Her captain in the first two
episodes, Georgiou, is played by Michelle Yeoh. And this is backed up
in the production, which also has a wider range of people than
previously working in almost any television show. Just look at the
credits, and you’ll see what I mean.
There has been some backlash to the casting online, but to borrow
from the Vulcans, there doesn’t seem to be any logical argument against
it. If you think
Star Trek should just be white men, you’re
missing the message of what the show is and has always been. Even
looking back to the 1960s episodes,
Star Trek was about
diversity. In this regard, it pushed the boundaries of what they could
get away with on network television, showing non-white-males in
positions of power.
Star Trek boasts the first interracial and
first homosexual kisses on broadcast network television, and had
African-American and female captains leading spin-offs in the 1990s. The
haters can’t possibly be real
Star Trek fans.
Where It Fits
Back to the story itself,
Discovery tells a missing part of
Star Trek
history and does it without majorly disrupting continuity. The
Klingon-Federation War was a bad one, as has been referenced, so it’s
understandable why the first season isn’t as bright and cheery as past
entries. It was also set in more dangerous times than we see in most
series. After all, Captain Pike wasn’t all that upbeat in “The Cage”
following a tragedy. This tone shift makes sense.
We get a deeper look at the Klingon Empire and why they came into
conflict with the Federation, which had little to do with the U.S.S.
starships themselves. Yes, there are more aliens serving on
Disco
than one might assume were in Starfleet at that point from past
entries. But that can be traced more to budgetary limitations of the
past than what was supposed to be. And characters like Harry Mudd (Rainn
Wilson taking over the role originated in the 1960s by Roger C.
Carmel), Sarek, and Amanda Grayson (Mia Kirshner) are shown earlier in
their time line.
Disco is careful to pay homage to the classic while looking
modern. The special effects and sets are thoroughly of today, as they
should be to avoid looking dated. But tricorders and phasers and
transporters are close enough to what’s been shown before to satisfy.
The uniforms are more
Enterprise than
TOS, but it
looks like the finale showed us background glimpses of the classic look,
which I expect Pike and crew will be wearing next season.
Continuity
The only major complaint I have here is the delta emblems everyone on the
Disco, the
U.S.S. Shenzou, and the admiralty all seem to be sporting. In classic
Trek, only the
Enterprise
crew wore this particular symbol, with other ships and stations having
different icons. However, it’s possible that everyone originally wore
the deltas, briefly switched to individualized badges ten years after
this, then switched back later, as shown in the spin-offs and films.
Given how
Disco seems to later fix things that look to be wrong, I’m willing to give them the benefit of the doubt here.
There are also countless Easter eggs for the eagle-eyed, from
Tribbles to Centaurian slugs. These are great for the fans. Georgiou
talking of “bread and circuses” might feel slightly odd, but it’s
appreciated. Even Clint Howard’s weird cameo as an Orion was great.
(Howard previously guest starred in
TOS, DS9, and
Enterprise). These little nuggets are perfect and appreciated.
Changes
There are some notable changes to the way
Discovery is presented as opposed to other
Star Trek series. The most important is that we finally get a serial, complex story. This isn’t the first time
Star Trek has done this;
Deep Space 9, and to a certain extent,
Enterprise, pursued long-running arcs, as well. But
Disco
is the first show to fully realize this superior method of
story-telling, with only one of the fifteen hours seeming mostly
stand-alone. This change allows for better character development and
growth. For instance, Commander Saru (Doug Jones) goes through quite an
arc, from disapproving coward to wise captain. This would not have been
possible, certainly not in a single season, in the past.
Some big swings
Disco takes, like the spore drive, seem ridiculous to exist without mention down the road. But because of how
Disco
fixes things, as mentioned above, I’m willing to give it the benefit of
the doubt for now that it will make sense later. Spock not mentioning a
sister, similarly, I can overlook because Spock is very private.
Besides, she’s not the first surprise sibling he’s sprung on us.
Additionally, the captain is not the lead, and that is welcome. We
finally get a different perspective on the starship, with a show mostly
told from below-decks. Both Tilly, a lowly cadet, and Burnham, not even a
commissioned officer for most of the season, give us fresh insight that
is more than welcome.
Weaknesses
For much of the year, I thought the biggest weakness was going to be
how the show handled the Voq / Ash Tyler twist. It was all over the
Internet long before the story was ready to reveal it. However, in
retrospect, I wonder if that wasn’t a genius distraction to keep the
real twist, Lorca being from the Mirror Universe, completely off the
radar. If so, brilliantly done.
Disco is not without its share of missteps, though, and a
lot have to do with production decisions. For instance, almost every
episode is right around forty-five minutes, the length of a regular
broadcast installment. Being on a streaming service, it shouldn’t try to
squeeze into such a narrow box. The result is plots that sometimes feel
wrapped up too quickly or missed opportunities between characters. Did
the way the handling of the bomb in the season finale make total sense?
No, and another minute of dialogue could have fixed that. But I feel
like these aren’t too distracting, and the show overall remains strong.
Of course, the worst thing about
Disco is that it’s exclusively on the way-overpriced CBS All Access service. But that can be blamed on CBS bullying the fans, not a S
tar Trek misstep.
Conclusion
Is
Discovery the
Star Trek we deserve? I think it’s
a little early to tell. A show like this takes time to prove whether
its journey is worth it, and that’s a good thing. This type of
storytelling is more ambitious, and when it succeeds, it’s aces. When it
fails, it’s frustrating as hell. I do think the signs so far are that
it’s a very good show. As long as it doesn’t screw anything huge up in
the mythology, it’ll go far.
Some will argue that
The Orville, a new show on FOX, is the
Star Trek heir apparent. But despite sharing some strong DNA with
The Next Generation, the Seth MacFarlane-led dramedy doesn’t quite have the same traditional
Star Trek spirit that
Discovery does. For this reason, as much as I like
The Orville, I disagree entirely with this assessment.
Whether you’re a Trekkie or not, I recommend giving
Discovery
a chance. It’s a pretty solid show by just about any measure. I hope it
lives long and prospers (preferably after moving to CBS-owned
Showtime). It certainly had an interesting freshman year, and the
cliffhanger of seeing the
Enterprise promises more goodness to come.
Catch
Star Trek: Discovery‘s
full first season through CBS All Access.