USA Not Likely to Be BENCHED For New Sitcom

Article first published as TV Review: 'Benched' - 'Pilot' on Blogcritics.

USA’s newest comedy, premiering this week, is called Benched. A smart lawyer named Nina (Eliza Coupe, Happy Endings, Scrubs) suffers a breakdown after being dumped by her fiance, Trent (Carter MacIntyre, Undercovers, Drop Dead Diva), and being passed over for promotion at her company. Her explosion is spectacular, and leaves her lucky to find employment in the crummy public defender’s office. Here, though, she might just find a sense of purpose amid the downtrodden misfits.

Benched doesn’t have much that one could call fresh and original. The Jerry Maguire-opening and tale of a person who finds deeper meaning than money is nothing new. There are quite a few other shows like it on television, both dramas and comedies, and so it seems like USA is just repeating a common structure. But there’s something charming and breezy about Benched that makes for good entertainment, even if it’s not exactly high quality.

One thing Benched has going for it is the quirky supportive cast. Like Brooklyn Nine-Nine, our lead is surrounded by a number of cartoonish players who give the proceedings a hyper reality. Sheryl (Maria Bamford, Adventure Time) looks to be very near the edge, even as she’s flighty enough to not let much in her day bother her. Oscar Nuñez plays Carlos, a role that, at first glance, seems quite similar to his part in The Office, non-showy, but still funny. Micah (Jolene Purdy, Under the Dome) keeps Nina going, the intern who tells the hard truths. Phil (Jay Harrington, Better Off Ted), a compulsive gambler, serves as a love interest and cautionary tale for Nina. And Trent is still around, often facing Nina in court. Because of these various personalities, I like the show.

Coupe is a great leading lady. She has proven her worth as part of an ensemble, and as much as I enjoy seeing her do that, she can also carry a program as the protagonist on her own. The second fiddle here is Harrington, who has been desperately missed on television, a few years having passed since his last starring role, and together the pair have terrific chemistry. It’s a no-brainer match, one audiences are sure to eat up. I did.

In the first episode, a lot of time is spent establishing the premise. We have to see Nina get to where she’s going to be. Still, it seems like there is time for her to start to find her footing, giving viewers an idea of what Benched will be on a regular basis. Nina spends time in the court room, sparring with Trent, Judge Nelson (Fred Melamed, Silk Stalkings), and a grumpy bailiff (Cedric Yarbrough, Reno 911!). While the case isn’t all that important, just watching the cast interact is good enough, and will probably be the best part of any installment.

Benched is genuinely humorous, well-crafted by creators Michaela Watkins (last see on-screen in Trophy Wife) and Damon Jones (Tammy). Even if they didn’t come up with many ideas of their own (maybe they were instructed not to by the network?), they show great talent in putting the various pieces together to make them work. Not every effort in this vein is nearly as good as Benched is. It takes some people who know what they’re doing to pull it off, and given the small writing resumes of the creators, this is a fine first big effort to be proud off.

Benched is far from perfect, and it has a lot of work to do if it wants to become anyone’s favorite show. Yet, there are some excellent ingredients here, well stirred, so it’s worth checking out. Given how funny those involved can be, it is likely there will be payoff if you start watching and stick with it.

Benched premieres Tuesday at 10:30 p.m. ET on USA.

THE CRAZY ONES Much "Improved"

Article first published as THE CRAZY ONES Much "Improved" on TheTVKing.

CBS's freshman comedy The Crazy Ones was funny from the start, but somewhere along the way, it has become so much more. It has found the perfect blend of heart and humor, often dwelling into deep pathos to find the laughs. This seems a natural direction for series star Robin Williams to go in, and the perfect ensemble surrounding him has tapped into the same vein.

This week's episode, "Dead and Improved," has a great illustration of a laugh out loud scene that will make you cry. A jingle writer that works for Simon (Williams) has died and his daughter, Melora (Missi Pyle, Big Fish), begs Simon to send him off right. The problem is, no one, Simon included, liked the man, making it super difficult to strike the 'wow' note in a eulogy that Melora seeks.

The story is so much more than this simple plot, though. Simon begins to look at his own legacy when faced with mortality. There is raw doubt in his eyes as he wonders if he's all show, no substance. His daughter, Sydney (Sarah Michelle Gellar) assures him that he's a good man who has had a lasting effect on the world. Through Sydney, Simon begins to see what Melora saw in her own dad, which allows him to find his speech, one that will make everyone laugh and cry at the same time.

It's very hard to serve a plot like this and to do it well. The Crazy Ones nails it. We have Williams, Gellar, and Pyle delivering knock-out performances with a brilliant script. It's full of nuance and meaning, one sure to ring true to many a viewer out there. Anyone who has parents or children can relate to this, making an excellent scene on its own mean something personal to those watching at home, providing connection for the audience.

"Dead and Improved" takes the idea of legacy a step further by tying the B plot into it, too. A Charmin rep, Mitchell (Kurt Fuller, Psych), is disowned by his company as he becomes unstable after his wife leaves him. Zach (James Wolk), Andrew (Hamish Linklater), and Lauren (Amanda Setton) feel obligated to set Mitchell right again, not to just turn him out on the street. Their sympathy continues even after he strips naked in their lobby.

The Mitchell thread weaves seamlessly into the A story, ending with Mitchell looking satisfied at the funeral, and doesn't even feel like a segregated tale. This cohesion is a strong selling factor for The Crazy Ones. Though it's an ensemble cast and each individual does have their own motivations and side stuff, the characters are very much part of a team, and it always feels like that. Simon and Syndey have moments with Mitchell, and Zach, Andrew, and Lauren are involved with Melora and the funeral. It's all inter-connected, and they all help one another out.

I also like how The Crazy Ones ties in enough reality so that it doesn't just feel like a cartoonish parody of the world. The excellent rendering of the Rice Krispie theme song at the beginning and Mitchell working for Charmin, with a bit of a real Charmin commercial played in the episode, really make the firm feel authentic. Not to mention, voice actor Fred Melamed gamely recurs as himself, including a couple of scenes in "Dead and Improved."

Most of this year's batch of new comedies has failed to resonate with viewers. While The Crazy Ones' ratings are modest, there is a special spark present that is lacking in most of its peers. The relationship between Simon and Sydney alone is worth watching for, and if you haven't had the opportunity to check this show out yet, please do, in case it soon becomes too late to do so.

The Crazy Ones airs Thursdays at 9 p.m. ET on CBS.